A space of her own: How Khabar Lahariya empowers Dalit and marginalised voices

It's Dalit History Month and there can be no better time to write about Khabar Lahariya, a women-led news resource that gives voice and space to Dalit

Trouble viewing this email? View in web browser

Sunday, April 21, 2024
By Namita Bhandare

It’s Dalit History Month and there can be no better time to write about Khabar Lahariya, a women-led news resource that gives voice and space to Dalit and marginalised women. Read on…

     

The Big Story

A space of her own: How Khabar Lahariya empowers Dalit and marginalised voices

credit: @khabarlahariya Instagram

On its website, Khabar Lahariya (KL) describes itself as “India’s only women-run brand of ethical and independent rural news”. Launched as the voice of marginalised communities in 2002, KL today has 589,000 subscribers to its YouTube channel and a viewership of 15 million across digital platforms, says Meera Devi, the managing editor.

But, it was not the first to tell the stories of women, and that too marginalised women, in Bundelkhand, a hilly region that extends from north Madhya Pradesh to southern Uttar Pradesh.

That honour goes to Mahila Dakiya, a single-page, two-sided leaflet written by hand in the local language, photocopied and then distributed in the early nineties.

When it went belly-up, the readers felt a real sense of loss. Meera, still a student when that happened, recalls: “It was our own paper that reflected our thoughts and issues.”

And, so, it seemed obvious and natural that many of the women who contributed to Mahila Dakya, went on to start a new publication. That was Khabar Lahariya.

Even 20 years later, the idea of a dedicated paper run by marginalised women, telling their stories and reflecting their concerns remains a unique concept.

As General Elections 2024 gathers pace, KL’s 25 women reporters are on the ground in Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Bihar, amplifying the voices you don’t often hear—women, the youth and marginalised communities—telling the stories you won’t often come across in mainstream media.

What, for instance, do Dalit voters in Bihar feel about the ruling party and the INDIA alliance? How do tribal women at Tikamgarh, Madhya Pradesh rate the literacy programmes targeted at them? What are the aspirations and expectations of Muslim woman from Bundelkhand?

If KL tracks these stories, it’s because it is uniquely placed to be able to do so. Many of its reporters come from the communities they are writing about, Dalit, Muslim, tribal, OBC and even dominant caste, voices often forgotten and ignored in the election buzz.

[There’s a subscription link for English-speaking readers to Khabar Lahariya here.]

Telling the story

Over 65% of the population lives in rural India. Yet, stories from the hinterland constitute a negligible proportion of the stories in mainstream media, generally falling into one of two categories—the sensational (as in the Hathras gang-rape) or those of agrarian distress and farmer suicides.

But what of the stories of aspiration and hope? Stories like that of KL managing editor Meera Devi, one of six daughters of a daily wage labourer, married at 14, who rebelled against social norms and her family to complete a post graduate degree? Why is it that we never hear these stories?

“Families didn’t want girls to study beyond the fifth grade,” says Meera, a post-graduate in political science. “They thought girls should be given enough education to manage household budgets and run their kitchens in the most economically efficient way.”

When KL was launched, Meera saw an opportunity, even though she was still a second year B.A. student. Back then the only journalists in the region were men, dominant-caste and educated.

KL had already decided to break the mould. Hire women. Train them. And look at stories through the eyes of marginalised women. This news would be delivered independently, minus sensationalism and, most crucially, told through a nariwadi chasmsa (feminist lens). “We wanted to bring in the voices that are supressed and don’t get a chance to be heard,” says Meera. “These are voices that are never given space by mainstream media.”

When caste is the story

A modern Indian horror story

In the beginning, it was really hard to get the women to apply for jobs, says Meera. The paper advertised vacancies but parents were wary about sending daughters to work and get ‘spoilt’.

The change was gradual. By focusing on local issues—a hand-pump that hadn’t been repaired for months, non-functioning school toilets—KL began making an impact. Earlier, government officials would shoo its reporters away. But as the stories got reported, the same officials were now held to account.

Meera was one of two reporters along with Kavita Bundelkhandi who reported on what came to be known as the Hathras gang-rape by four dominant-caste men of a 19-year-old Dalit girl in September 2020. The woman was shifted to a Delhi hospital for treatment of her grievous injuries but died two weeks later.

[Read An Attack in Hathras, And a Story of our Times by Khabar Lahariya in collaboration with Article-14.]

When her body was taken back to Hathras to be cremated, UP police denied permission to her own family to attend her funeral, cremating her instead late at night.

“We got a lot of criticism online and offline for writing about her caste,” says Meera. This was, after all, a violent crime against a woman. But, she adds, “It was essential to talk about caste in this case.” It was the fact that she was Dalit that made her more vulnerable to rape. The fact of her caste gave impunity to the dominant-caste men to rape her. It emboldened the police to try to surreptitiously cremate her. It meant that her family was denied the dignity of even a last farewell.

In the end, three of the four men were acquitted by a UP court. The fourth was found guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to homicide. He was not found guilty of rape.

Caste was, in fact, the story.

Smells like an election

The numbers are a disgrace. Just 237, or 8.3% of all 2831 candidates, contesting the first two of the seven-phased general elections are women, finds analysis by The Quantum Hub (TQH), a policy think tank.

Of these, three in four, 75.5%, are either contesting as independents (87) or being fielded by unrecognised parties (92).

The national parties have together put up 46 women. Nobody does well, but the BJP is the least worst at 15%, the CPI (M) follows with 13% and the Congress makes a poor show at 10%.

One third of all constituencies in the first two phases have zero women contestants.

“Without affirmative action, it seems impossible to increase women’s representation at all levels of legislatures,” says Aparajita Bharti, founding partner, TQH Will things improve? I’m happy to be proved wrong, but please don’t hold your breath.

To Randeep Surjewala of the Congress party goes the dubious distinction of this election’s first campaign ban by the Election Commission. The 48-hour ban on campaigning is for making “undignified, uncivilised and vulgar” remarks against BJP member of Parliament Hema Malini, a charge Sujrewala denies, saying a video clip cited by the BJP was ‘doctored’.

Sunita Kejriwal has picked up the slack on behalf of the Aam Aadmi Party as a “star campaigner” in Gujarat where AAP is contesting two of the 26 Lok Sabha seats in polls to be held on May 7. Reports suggest that the travails of the 58-year-old former Indian Revenue Service officer whose husband, Arvind Kejriwal remains in jail will be highlighted in order to appeal to women voters, particularly in Delhi where they make up 46% of the total electorate.

Watch

REUTERS/MOHAMMED SALEM

You cannot see their faces, one behind a veil, the other in a shroud and yet what seeps through is the haunting grief of 36-year-old Inas Abu Maamar as she cradles the body of her five-year-old niece, Saly who was killed in an Israeli strike at Nasser hospital in Khan Younis on October 17.

Reuters’ photographer Mohammed Salem was at the hospital morgue. There amidst the throng and chaos of frantic relatives, he saw Inas cradling the body of her niece.

For this photograph Salem won the 2024 World Press Photo of the Year.

Unrelated to the award, UN Women earlier this week said 10,000 Palestinian women have been killed by Israeli bombardment. Of these, 6,000 are mothers, leaving 19,000 children orphaned.

News you might have missed

CREDIT, LIVELAW

A six-member committee headed by the cabinet secretary, will look into the issues faced by the LGBTQI+ community. One of the chief reasons argued in favour of marriage equality was to enable same-sex partners to have the rights of heterosexual married couples—the right to inherit and adopt, for instance. While the Supreme Court refused to grant marriage rights, it also denied the community the right to adopt or have a civil union. However, the apex court asked the government to set up a committee to understand the issues faced by the community.

A key provision in UP’s anti-conversion law, aka love jihad law, has resulted in a good deal of confusion on whether interfaith couples who are living together, even those in consensual relationships, are entitled to police protection Analysis by The Indian Express finds that protection was denied to a dozen couples who had filed petitions seeking protection from the Allahabad high court. In eight of these petitions, the court noted that such relationships had been criminalised.

In two other petitions, the court did grant protection to the couples but on the condition that they had to have a marriage registered under the provisions of the new law. The new law prohibits conversion for the purpose of marriage and requires prior sanction from the state for religious conversion for any other reason.

The anti-conversion law in UP and other BJP-ruled states where it exists has been under challenge in the Supreme Court since 2020 on the grounds that it violates Constitutional rights to privacy, liberty and dignity.

Nestle is under fire for the sugar content in its baby food sold in developing countries, including India and Africa. Nestle India officials told Mint that it had over five years reduced upto 30% of added sugars across its infant cereal range, including Cerelac. At three grams of sugar per serving that is still unacceptable, especially when you consider that the same cereal sold in markets like Switzerland has no added sugar.

Field notes

The orgasm gap

New research helps explain why lesbian women report more orgasms than straight women. The difference, finds the study, could be attributed in part at least to ‘sexual scripts’ or expectations of sexual performance based on what men and women see in movies, TV and even porn. In this script, heterosexual sex prioritises the man’s orgasm and while there might be foreplay, sex ends when the man has an orgasm.

Women who have sex with women are more likely to engage in non-penetrative acts where an orgasm for both partners is a priority.

The study was published in Sage. Read here.

Around the world

credit: BBC

Day one of the first-ever criminal trial of a former US president saw lawyers argue on how much Donald Trump’s sex life could be described before a yet-to-be-finalised jury. The “hush money trial” follows revelations by several women, including writer E Jean Carrol who won a suit for defamation, claiming that Trump had either sexually assaulted or mistreated them. Among them is adult film actress ‘Stormy’ Daniels. The charge against Trump is that he paid her $130,000 to keep her mouth shut during his 2016 campaign—not illegal by the way—and falsified business accounts to make that payment (totally illegal).

Bruce Lehrmann, an Australian government employee who was accused by a colleague of raping her in Parliament while she was inebriated, has lost a civil defamation suit he had filed against a TV channel that had first reported it.

Brittany Higgins had said on national television in 2021 that she had been sexually assaulted two years earlier by Lehrmann. She said she felt pressure from the government to not report.

The charge resulted in a massive backlash against Australia’s male-dominated political establishment and the eventual defeat of the conservative government. But, there was no legal conclusion to the case. On Monday, a judge ruled that it was ‘more likely than not’ that Lehrmann had raped Higgings

At the Venice biennale, the Vatican’s official pavilion is housed at the working Giudecca women’s prison. The prison building was once a former convent dating to the 13th century as well as a home for reformed sex workers.

Pope Francis himself will be visiting on April 28, and it will, reports The Guardian, be the first pontifical visit to the Biennale since it was founded in 1895.

The Vatican pavilion houses works of art including a 1999 sculpture by Maurizio Cattelan depicting Pope John Paul II struck down by a meteorite. Tours around the prison can be booked by the public and include those led by inmates.

        

Were you forwarded this email? Did you stumble upon it online? Sign up here.

That’s it for this week. If you have a tip, feedback, criticism, please write to me at: namita.bhandare@gmail.com.
Produced by Nirmalya Dutta nirmalya.dutta@htdigital.in.

Get the Hindustan Times app and read premium stories
 Google Play Store  App Store
View in Browser | Privacy Policy | Contact us You received this email because you signed up for HT Newsletters or because it is included in your subscription. Copyright © HT Digital Streams. All Rights Reserved

--
Click Here to unsubscribe from this newsletter.

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form